EURUSD Bid: --
USDJPY Bid: --
GBPUSD Bid: --
USDCHF Bid: --
AUDUSD Bid: --
USDCAD Bid: --
NZDUSD Bid: --
EURGBP Bid: --
GBPJPY Bid: --
WTI Bid: --
BRENT Bid: --
XAUUSD Bid: --
XAGUSD Bid: --
SPX500 Bid: --
DAX40 Bid: --
US30 Bid: --
JPN225 Bid: --
NAS100 Bid: --
UK100 Bid: --
BTCUSD Bid: --
ETHUSD Bid: --
LTCUSD Bid: --
XRPUSD Bid: --
EURUSD Bid: --
USDJPY Bid: --
GBPUSD Bid: --
USDCHF Bid: --
AUDUSD Bid: --
USDCAD Bid: --
NZDUSD Bid: --
EURGBP Bid: --
GBPJPY Bid: --
WTI Bid: --
BRENT Bid: --
XAUUSD Bid: --
XAGUSD Bid: --
SPX500 Bid: --
DAX40 Bid: --
US30 Bid: --
JPN225 Bid: --
NAS100 Bid: --
UK100 Bid: --
BTCUSD Bid: --
ETHUSD Bid: --
LTCUSD Bid: --
XRPUSD Bid: --

Gambling or Derivatives: CFTC Rulemaking Exposes a Structural Divide Over Prediction Markets

Posted: 4th May 2026

The CFTC has closed public comment on its proposed prediction market rule, receiving more than 1,500 responses.

What came back was not a policy debate but a structural deadlock: event contracts as financial derivatives, or event contracts as gambling dressed in legal cover.

Singapore Summit: Meet the largest APAC brokers you know (and those you still don't!)

As Better Markets put it, “prediction markets offer the ability to gamble without the regulations that normally accompany gambling.”

The volume alone signals that this is a fight over market structure and over who gets to regulate a fast-growing market already handling billions in volume and expanding rapidly across new asset classes.

The Financial Case

Coinbase, Kalshi, and investors such as Andreessen Horowitz all argued that event contracts are swaps that fall under the CFTC's federal authority.

Their argument centers on function: price discovery, information aggregation, and hedging — the same pillars used to justify traditional derivatives markets.

“Event contracts are ‘swaps’ that Congress has placed squarely within the CFTC’s authority,” wrote Faryar Shirzad, Coinbase’s chief policy officer. Coinbase went further, calling prediction markets “a public good with broad benefits.”

The industry wants the CFTC to assert exclusive jurisdiction and preempt the state-level gaming laws it describes as a barrier to market access. Without federal cover, operators face a patchwork of licensing regimes that vary by state — and in some cases outright prohibitions.

Operators also warned that restricting regulated venues would not eliminate demand, but displace it. “When a contract type is prohibited… demand migrates to unregulated offshore platforms,” Kalshi noted.

The Gambling Case

State gaming regulators from Tennessee, Missouri, and Pennsylvania, along with consumer group Better Markets, pushed back hard. Their core argument is legal, not just moral: these contracts lack a direct economic purpose and therefore fall outside the definition of legitimate derivatives.

“Nobody ‘trades’ on sporting events. People bet on sporting events,” Better Markets wrote. In their view, such contracts are not just misclassified — they are “contrary to the public interest.”

Critics argue that if most Americans experience these contracts as a bet, then functionally they are a bet — regardless of what the underlying instrument is called.

What the CFTC Decides Next

The more consequential argument may be behavioral rather than legal. Critics argue that contracts on elections, war, or death do more than resemble gambling — they risk creating perverse incentives around real-world outcomes, from political processes to geopolitical events.

As Rep. Paul Tonko argued in his submission, most Americans experience these contracts as gambling.

For brokers and trading firms eyeing this space, the outcome is binary. A ruling in the industry's favor would confirm federal preemption and allow integration of event contracts into standard trading accounts.

A ruling against would push regulatory authority back to the states, where a license-by-license buildout becomes the only path forward — slow, expensive, and uncertain in states where gambling law is deliberately broad.

The CFTC is to decide deciding whether prediction markets become part of the global financial system — or remain classified as a form of regulated gambling. In practice, that means choosing between Wall Street’s infrastructure and the regulatory logic of Las Vegas.

This article was written by Tanya Chepkova at www.financemagnates.com.

Source: Finance Magnates

Follow us on
Website Managed by BuiltByGo
Disclaimer: The information provided on FX Axe is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial advice. Trading Foreign Exchange (FX), Contracts for Difference (CFDs), and other leveraged financial products involves a high level of risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Leverage can work both to your advantage and disadvantage, and as a result, you may lose more than your initial investment. Before deciding to trade FX, CFDs, or any other financial instrument, you should carefully consider your investment objectives, level of experience, and risk tolerance. You should not invest money that you cannot afford to lose. It is strongly advised that you seek independent financial advice if you have any doubts. FX Axe does not provide investment, tax, legal, or financial advice of any kind. We may receive compensation from brokers and partners featured on this website, but such relationships do not influence our reviews or recommendations. All reviews are based on our own opinions and research and should not be interpreted as endorsements or guarantees of any service. Past performance is not indicative of future results. The trading of FX and CFDs carries a significant risk of loss. By using this website, you acknowledge that FX Axe bears no responsibility for any losses you may incur from your trading activities or reliance on information provided here.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the links and references on FX Axe may relate to third-party brokers or service providers. In certain cases, we may receive compensation if you choose to engage with these providers through our website. This helps support the ongoing operation of the site and allows us to continue publishing content at no direct cost to our readers. Our content is created with the aim of being informative and useful. While commercial relationships may exist, we strive to ensure that the information presented remains objective and based on our own research and perspective.
cross