EURUSD Bid: --
USDJPY Bid: --
GBPUSD Bid: --
USDCHF Bid: --
AUDUSD Bid: --
USDCAD Bid: --
NZDUSD Bid: --
EURGBP Bid: --
GBPJPY Bid: --
WTI Bid: --
BRENT Bid: --
XAUUSD Bid: --
XAGUSD Bid: --
SPX500 Bid: --
DAX40 Bid: --
US30 Bid: --
JPN225 Bid: --
NAS100 Bid: --
UK100 Bid: --
BTCUSD Bid: --
ETHUSD Bid: --
LTCUSD Bid: --
XRPUSD Bid: --
EURUSD Bid: --
USDJPY Bid: --
GBPUSD Bid: --
USDCHF Bid: --
AUDUSD Bid: --
USDCAD Bid: --
NZDUSD Bid: --
EURGBP Bid: --
GBPJPY Bid: --
WTI Bid: --
BRENT Bid: --
XAUUSD Bid: --
XAGUSD Bid: --
SPX500 Bid: --
DAX40 Bid: --
US30 Bid: --
JPN225 Bid: --
NAS100 Bid: --
UK100 Bid: --
BTCUSD Bid: --
ETHUSD Bid: --
LTCUSD Bid: --
XRPUSD Bid: --

The CFTC Says 'Gaming' Is Undefined: What Actually Separates a Prediction Market from a Sportsbook

Posted: 10th Sep 2026

The words that let the CFTC bar an event contract from a federal exchange are "gaming" and "involve." On 20 August, Chairman Michael S. Selig told the agency's new Innovation Advisory Committee that the statute defines neither, leaving contracts "at risk of rejection based upon arbitrary whims or political biases."

ProphetX CEO Dean Sisun had filed a comment letter ahead of the same meeting arguing that a two-sided, peer-to-peer exchange under federal oversight "is not simply another way to package the state sportsbook model."

The CFTC register lists ProphetX LLC as a designated contract market from 11 June 2026, so its intervention comes from inside the federal lane it wants protected.

Read together, the regulator and the operator are making the same diagnosis from different positions: the line the whole category stands on is not fully written down. The machinery answers it anyway.

How the Models Differ

Three Tests Draw the Line

The table gives the short version. The longer test starts with three mechanics: price formation, counterparty risk, and settlement.

Who Sets the Price?

A bookmaker publishes its own odds and moves them to balance its book and keep its margin inside the price. On an event-contract exchange, price comes out of an order book.

Kalshi's explainer says its contracts trade between one and 99 cents, settle at $1 or zero, and read as live probability: a question with a 40% chance of resolving yes should trade around 40 cents.

Sisun makes the same point in regulatory terms: preserve competitive price formation and venue neutrality.

Who Takes the Other Side?

At a sportsbook, the operator is the counterparty to every ticket, and your win is its loss.

An exchange matches you against another participant: a customer with the opposite view, or a market maker quoting both sides. ProphetX describes its model in those terms, with users trading directly with one another while the venue takes no directional position.

Sisun's second recommendation draws the same line inside the exchange camp: affiliated liquidity should supplement independent flow, not replace it.

If the venue's own affiliate is on the other side of most customer trades, the model starts to look less like an exchange and more like a sportsbook.

How does the position end?

A bet is a claim on the operator: it pays at the locked odds when the book grades the event, and until then it exists only on the operator's books.

An event contract is a listed instrument. Kalshi's version settles at $1 if the outcome happens and zero if it does not; both sides of a matched pair post the full dollar when they trade. Until the event is resolved, the holder can also sell the contract in the order book at the current market price.

Where the Money Comes From

The distinction shows up most clearly when the same outcome is priced in both models. A sportsbook turns it into a bet against the house; an exchange turns it into a contract between two market participants.

The Same Coin Flip, Priced Twice

Run an illustrative $1,000 through each model; the figures are assumptions, not any firm's terms. At a US sportsbook, a common two-way price is -110 on both sides: stake $110 to win $100.

If $500 is staked on each side, the book collects $1,000, pays the winners about $955 including returned stake, and keeps roughly $45. The margin lives inside the accepted price.

On an exchange, a 50/50 event trades around 50 cents, so the same $1,000 buys roughly 2,000 contracts before fees. The venue earns a fee on the transaction, alongside the price rather than inside it.

Who Carries the Outcome Risk?

The bookmaker carries it. An unbalanced book is real exposure to the result, which is why odds move and why books manage which bets they take. The exchange carries none of it if the venue remains neutral. A venue with no position has no stake in who wins, only in volume.

Ask who loses money when the customer wins; if the answer is the operator, that is the sportsbook model, whatever the product calls itself.

Which Regulator Claims Each Model

The answer starts with federal designation, but it does not end there. State gambling regulators still claim authority when the product reaches residents through sports-outcome markets.

The Federal Claim Runs through Designation

For a retail-facing US prediction market, the federal route runs through designation as a contract market under the CFTC.

The Commission's March notice said any prediction-market venue offering swaps or futures to the general public must register as a designated contract market.

Novig launched nationally on 4 August, after the CFTC granted designated contract market status to its Ludlow Exchange LLC subsidiary on 16 June. ProphetX LLC is listed separately on the CFTC register as designated from 11 June.

Selig told the committee the Commission would defend that jurisdiction in court and exercise it. Amendments to Parts 38 and 40, expected soon, would modernize listing rules and add retail protections.

The package also includes a rewrite of Rule 40.11, which bars contracts that involve, relate to, or reference terrorism, assassination, war, gaming, or activity unlawful under state or federal law.

The problem is that "gaming" and "involve" do most of the work, but neither term is defined. Sisun's third recommendation attacks the gap from the operator side: a conditions-based Section 4(c) framework with categorical standards for settlement, surveillance and integrity instead of contract-by-contract review.

States Still Claim the Same Product

Federal designation does not by itself settle how states treat sports-outcome products offered to their residents. The CFTC sees a listed event contract; state gaming regulators see a wager on a sporting event and apply their own gambling statutes.

That is the conflict behind the Nevada case. A court barred Kalshi from serving state residents, and the Nevada Gaming Control Board later accused the company of failing to stop trading from inside the state. The regulator has asked the court for $120,000 a day from Kalshi for the alleged violations.

The courts are now testing whether federal derivatives law displaces those state claims. On 28 August, the Ninth Circuit held that Kalshi had not shown the Commodity Exchange Act likely preempted Nevada's gaming regulations for sports event contracts.

On 2 September, New Jersey's attorney general asked the US Supreme Court to review whether sports wagers on prediction markets can avoid state sports-gambling laws.

The CFTC's prediction-market rulemaking had already drawn more than 1,500 comments across the same divide: derivatives infrastructure on one side, gambling in financial dress on the other.

Where the Models Are Converging

The mechanical line is cleanest when a sportsbook is taking bets and an exchange is listing neutral contracts. The commercial market is less tidy.

Sportsbook-style products are appearing on federally designated exchanges, while sportsbook operators are looking at the CFTC route. Novig is the clearest example on the exchange side.

The company said its first week after national launch produced more than $125 million of notional volume, and parlays were roughly a third of the activity. A parlay, the signature sportsbook product, now runs at scale through a federally designated exchange.

The traffic also moves in the other direction. DraftKings filed its first event-contract templates with the CFTC in May for DKeX, pursuing the federal route as an alternative to state-by-state sportsbook licensing.

That is why the CFTC's June proposal matters. It would not bless every sports contract simply because it sits on an exchange. The proposal would define "gaming" and "involve," set public-interest factors, and treat player-injury and discrete-action contracts as likely contrary to the public interest.

The product menus are converging, even if the operating models remain different.

Why Should Brokers and Exchanges Care?

Brokers and exchanges are not only watching this category from the outside. Some are exploring listings, distribution, liquidity, technology or client access as prediction-market volumes grow.

FM's guide to why brokers and exchanges are racing in covers that commercial case, including the growth from $9 billion of volume in 2024 to $40 billion in 2025.

The regulatory question is therefore also an operating question. Before a firm lists, routes, white-labels or promotes event contracts, it needs to know whether the product behaves like a neutral exchange instrument or like a wager against the house.

The answer sits in the mechanics: price formation, counterparty exposure, settlement, collateral and venue neutrality. The checklist below is the structural screen to run before the next launch, partnership or product review.

What This Means Now

As of early September 2026, the federal regulator has said its statutory dividing line is undefined and has proposed rules to start defining it.

Operators are filing letters to shape those rules, states are enforcing gambling law against designated venues, and product menus on both sides are converging.

Until the CFTC finalizes those definitions, firms will still need to classify products by how they actually work.

Reusable Checklist: Event Contract or Sportsbook?

Use the checks below as a first classification screen. If most answers are "yes," the product looks closer to a sportsbook; if most are "no," it looks closer to an event-contract exchange.

  • Does the operator post and move the odds?
  • Is the operator the customer's counterparty?
  • Can the operator profit from the customer's loss on the event?
  • Does the customer mainly exit through settlement or an operator cash-out quote?
  • Is the payout based on locked betting odds rather than $1/zero contract settlement?
  • Is the product authorised under a state gaming licence rather than a CFTC designation?
  • Does customer money sit inside a state sportsbook client-money framework?
  • Would a state regulator treat the product as gambling if offered to residents?
  • If the venue failed, would the customer's claim be against the operator rather than against segregated collateral or exchange/clearing rules?

If the answers are mixed, the product needs deeper legal review before launch, distribution or promotion.

This article was written by Tanya Chepkova at www.financemagnates.com.

Source: Finance Magnates

Follow us on
Website Managed by BuiltByGo
Disclaimer: The information provided on FX Axe is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial advice. Trading Foreign Exchange (FX), Contracts for Difference (CFDs), and other leveraged financial products involves a high level of risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Leverage can work both to your advantage and disadvantage, and as a result, you may lose more than your initial investment. Before deciding to trade FX, CFDs, or any other financial instrument, you should carefully consider your investment objectives, level of experience, and risk tolerance. You should not invest money that you cannot afford to lose. It is strongly advised that you seek independent financial advice if you have any doubts. FX Axe does not provide investment, tax, legal, or financial advice of any kind. We may receive compensation from brokers and partners featured on this website, but such relationships do not influence our reviews or recommendations. All reviews are based on our own opinions and research and should not be interpreted as endorsements or guarantees of any service. Past performance is not indicative of future results. The trading of FX and CFDs carries a significant risk of loss. By using this website, you acknowledge that FX Axe bears no responsibility for any losses you may incur from your trading activities or reliance on information provided here.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the links and references on FX Axe may relate to third-party brokers or service providers. In certain cases, we may receive compensation if you choose to engage with these providers through our website. This helps support the ongoing operation of the site and allows us to continue publishing content at no direct cost to our readers. Our content is created with the aim of being informative and useful. While commercial relationships may exist, we strive to ensure that the information presented remains objective and based on our own research and perspective.
cross