Max's Daily Chop
I must admit, I was beginning to worry about Donald Trump. Not because he'd done something particularly outrageous, which is reassuringly familiar territory, but because, for a few extraordinary days, he hadn't. The Republicans had suffered a historic defeat in the American midterms, Democrats had seized control of both chambers of Congress, and the President appeared to be responding with something approaching the behaviour of a grown-up. After months of increasingly bizarre rallies, accusations about electoral integrity and a campaign that occasionally resembled the final stages of a particularly unpleasant family argument, Trump seemed almost restrained. Perhaps, I wondered, the scale of the defeat had finally registered. Perhaps somebody had managed to explain that losing both houses of Congress was not, in fact, a tremendous victory. Perhaps the chickens were coming home to roost, and the farmer had finally noticed.
Well, we needn't have worried. Donald Trump is back, and he's brought the entire circus with him.
The Democrats' sweeping victory on 3 November has fundamentally changed the political landscape in Washington. For the first time in his second presidency, Trump faces the prospect of a Congress controlled entirely by his opponents, with the power to investigate his administration, summon witnesses, demand documents and examine the extraordinary network of commercial relationships that has developed around the presidency. The Democrats won't formally take control until January, but the warning shots have already begun. Robert Garcia, the incoming chairman of the House Oversight Committee, offered the wonderfully economical instruction, "LAWYER UP." Senator Ron Wyden went one better with a single word: "Subpoenas." It was rather like watching a group of accountants arrive at a particularly extravagant stag weekend and announce that they would now be examining everybody's receipts.
And those receipts, it turns out, could make for some fascinating reading.
The swamp has become rather profitable
We've already examined the extraordinary expansion of the Trump family's commercial interests in previous editions of Max's Daily Chop, so I won't drag you through the entire catalogue again. Suffice to say, between cryptocurrency, investment ventures, international business relationships and the increasingly blurred boundaries between the presidency and private enterprise, there is a substantial amount for the incoming Democratic Congress to examine. Readers wanting the full picture can refer back to our earlier investigation into the Trump family's business dealings, including the questions surrounding who has benefited, how those relationships developed and what they might mean for the integrity of public office.
The important development now is that those questions are about to acquire something considerably more powerful than newspaper headlines: congressional subpoena authority. As Reuters reported in its investigation of the family's commercial interests, Democrats have been preparing to examine transactions and relationships involving the President's family, associates and companies that have cultivated close ties to the administration. The difference is that they are no longer simply promising investigations from the opposition benches. Come January, they will have the committee chairmanships, investigative resources and legal mechanisms to begin asking questions that the White House may find rather more difficult to ignore.
And this is where the political consequences become particularly interesting. Trump has spent much of his career operating on the assumption that aggression is the best form of defence. Attack the critic, discredit the institution, question the motives of the investigator and, if necessary, announce that the entire process is a conspiracy. It is an approach that has served him extraordinarily well, not least because his supporters have often interpreted the attacks against him as evidence that he must be doing something right. But congressional investigations are not television interviews. They involve documents, testimony, legal obligations and, occasionally, people who have rather less enthusiasm for taking the blame on somebody else's behalf.
The protection racket has lost its majority
The real significance of the midterm result is not simply that Democrats can frustrate Trump's legislative ambitions. It is that the machinery of congressional oversight is changing hands. Committee chairmanships, investigative budgets, hearing schedules and subpoena powers will move to politicians who have spent the past two years watching the administration operate with comparatively little resistance from Capitol Hill. They are not short of material, and they are certainly not short of enthusiasm.
The incoming Democratic leadership has already identified Elon Musk, Stephen Miller and major corporations among its potential investigative targets. There are also questions surrounding immigration enforcement, the administration's handling of the Iran conflict and the conduct of senior officials. Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth is facing renewed political pressure, with Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries indicating support for impeachment proceedings against him. The White House, unsurprisingly, has dismissed the prospect of these investigations as politically motivated. But the essential difference is that, come January, Democrats will have the institutional authority to do considerably more than complain.
And Trump knows it. His immediate response to the electoral disaster has been to rearrange the furniture in the White House, replacing Susie Wiles as chief of staff with Stephen Miller, a man whose political philosophy is not generally associated with compromise, moderation or the gentle resolution of disagreements. Miller has been one of the administration's most influential architects of hardline immigration policy, and his promotion suggests that Trump is not responding to the electorate's rebuke by moving towards the political centre. Quite the opposite. Having lost the confidence of a substantial portion of the electorate, he appears to have concluded that what the White House really needs is a little more Stephen Miller. It's rather like responding to a house fire by appointing the chief arsonist as head of building maintenance.
But the most entertaining development of the weekend involved a personnel decision so gloriously absurd that it deserves its own chapter in the increasingly extraordinary history of this administration.
The curious case of Dana White. And Dana White.
On Saturday, Trump announced that he had offered the position of White House press secretary to Dana White, the enormously successful and occasionally combustible boss of the Ultimate Fighting Championship. Now, Dana White is undoubtedly an impressive businessman, an accomplished promoter and a man who has spent much of his professional life organising situations in which people punch one another in the face. Whether that qualifies him to explain American foreign policy to the world's press is another matter entirely. Trump described him as a fighter and warrior, suggested that he might bring several UFC stars along as assistants and enthusiastically encouraged him to accept the job. It was a rather unusual approach to government communications, although perhaps not entirely surprising from an administration that increasingly appears to regard political disagreement as a full-contact sport.
But then the story became considerably funnier. Because, as it turns out, there is another Dana White. Dana W. White is a Black woman who served as the Pentagon's chief spokesperson under Defence Secretary James Mattis during Trump's first administration. She is an experienced communications professional, familiar with the demands of government, national security and dealing with difficult questions from journalists. In other words, precisely the sort of person one might reasonably expect to be considered for the vacant White House press secretary position. And this has produced a rather magnificent theory about what actually happened inside the White House.
According to reporting by The Independent, speculation has spread that somebody inside the administration suggested Dana W. White for the position, meaning the former Pentagon spokesperson. Trump, hearing the name, may have assumed they meant his old friend from the UFC and promptly announced the offer to the world before anybody could intervene. Suddenly, the White House found itself discussing the possibility of appointing a cage-fighting promoter as its chief spokesperson, complete with an entourage of professional fighters. And once the President had publicly committed himself, the people around him were potentially left with the familiar problem of explaining an apparent mistake without actually telling the President he had made one.
Now, to be clear, this remains a theory rather than an established account of what happened. But it is an extraordinarily plausible-sounding one, and certainly more entertaining than the official explanation, which is that Trump was simply having a joke. Indeed, it seems almost perfectly designed for an administration in which the President's instincts so frequently become government policy before anybody has had the opportunity to check whether they make sense. Trump subsequently told reporters that he had been kidding all along, insisting that he had merely been having some fun. Of course he was. Just as one imagines that everybody inside the White House had been laughing uproariously while trying to work out why the proposed press secretary was suddenly discussing which professional fighters he might bring to a government briefing.
The other Dana White, meanwhile, found herself receiving congratulatory messages for a job she hadn't been offered. She responded on LinkedIn by pointing out that people had confused the two names, noting that her experience involved facing questions from Pentagon journalists rather than stepping into an octagon. It is difficult to imagine a more perfect illustration of the current state of presidential recruitment. The woman with the relevant experience was suddenly explaining that she wasn't the candidate, while the man whose principal qualification involved organising fights was apparently being considered for one of the most important communications jobs in the world.
And if you thought that was the end of it, Trump then shared a cartoon depicting the UFC's Dana White overseeing a White House press briefing in which fighters attacked journalists. An extraordinary image, even by the standards of a presidency that has never been particularly enthusiastic about press scrutiny. In the space of a weekend, the administration had moved from the prospect of appointing a professional government spokesperson to circulating images of journalists being physically assaulted by mixed martial artists. Churchillian it is not.
There is, however, a more serious point beneath the comedy. Trump is heading into perhaps the most difficult period of his second presidency, facing an opposition-controlled Congress preparing to investigate his administration and commercial relationships. And his instinctive response appears to be to surround himself with people who will fight for him, whether politically, rhetorically or, apparently, in an octagon. The Dana White affair is amusing precisely because it is so ridiculous. But it also illustrates a White House in which personal loyalty, theatrical aggression and the President's immediate impulses increasingly seem to take precedence over conventional qualifications and institutional discipline.
The markets have noticed. And so has the rest of the world.
For financial markets, the consequences of the midterms extend well beyond the political theatre. The Democratic sweep has introduced a new period of uncertainty around taxation, regulation, government spending, trade policy and the administration's relationship with corporate America. Investors initially reacted with caution, with Asian technology shares falling, Treasury yields declining and the dollar weakening as the results became clear. The prospect of congressional scrutiny over artificial intelligence, cryptocurrency and companies closely associated with the administration is particularly relevant to sectors that have benefited from the expectation of a relatively accommodating regulatory environment.
But investors should be careful not to confuse political defeat with presidential impotence. Trump retains substantial executive authority, particularly over trade, and Democratic control of Congress does not automatically mean the reversal of his tariffs or economic policies. As Reuters explained in its analysis of the post-election trade landscape, any attempt to overturn significant measures could encounter presidential vetoes and the procedural difficulties of the Senate. What the result does create is a far more confrontational political environment, in which government policy, corporate relationships and the administration's use of executive power will face greater public examination. For markets, that means uncertainty, and uncertainty is rarely something investors welcome with open arms.
Then, of course, there is Iran. The war has already inflicted considerable damage on global energy markets, raised fuel costs and complicated the economic outlook for governments around the world. The election result has introduced another layer of uncertainty over how Trump intends to approach the conflict. Some regional observers believe the defeat could encourage him to pursue a diplomatic settlement, particularly as American voters have grown increasingly weary of the economic consequences. Others fear that a politically weakened President could be tempted to demonstrate strength through renewed military escalation. Neither possibility can be dismissed, and the difference between them is rather important if you happen to be trading oil, currencies or almost anything else affected by geopolitical risk.
This is the great contradiction of Trump's position. He has lost control of Congress, but he has not lost the presidency. He remains capable of making decisions with enormous consequences for international markets, American foreign policy and global security. Yet the domestic political environment in which those decisions are made has changed dramatically. The President who once enjoyed the protection of Republican congressional majorities must now contend with an opposition that has both the motivation and, shortly, the authority to investigate his decisions. And if the past decade has taught us anything, it is that Donald Trump rarely responds to feeling cornered by becoming more accommodating.
The chickens are coming home. But who is going to open the door?
There is an important qualification to all this, and it concerns the Democrats themselves. Winning an election is one thing; demonstrating that you deserve to govern is quite another. Their victory was driven in significant part by voters' frustration over living costs, economic uncertainty and the direction of the country. According to a Reuters/Ipsos poll, 48% of registered voters identified the cost of living as the leading issue determining their vote. Democrats would therefore be making an enormous mistake if they interpreted their victory as an invitation to spend the next two years doing nothing but conducting investigations into Donald Trump.
The investigations matter. Accountability matters. If the President, his family or his associates have improperly benefited from the machinery of government, the public has every right to know. But those investigations must ultimately serve a broader political purpose: demonstrating that the rules apply to everybody, that public office is not a private commercial opportunity and that the institutions of American democracy can still function independently of the people who temporarily occupy them. If Democrats can establish that principle while addressing the economic concerns that brought them to power, they could fundamentally reshape the political landscape ahead of 2028. If they become consumed by revenge, they risk handing Trump the very grievance narrative on which he has built his career.
And that is why the next two years could prove so extraordinary. Trump has spent much of his political life presenting himself as the victim of a corrupt establishment, even while occupying the most powerful office within it. He has portrayed investigations as persecution, criticism as disloyalty and political opposition as an attack on the country itself. But the scale of the Democrats' victory suggests that a substantial number of Americans are no longer persuaded by the performance. They want answers about the economy, the war, the conduct of government and the increasingly blurred distinction between public responsibility and private enrichment.
The coming investigations may finally establish just how much of that swamp has been flowing through Trump's own backyard. And the great irony is that a President who spent years attacking the institutions designed to hold government accountable may now discover what happens when those institutions begin functioning again.
Perhaps Dana White really would have been the perfect press secretary after all. When the subpoenas start arriving, I suspect there will be quite a few people in the White House wishing they could settle matters with a right hook. Unfortunately for Donald Trump, congressional subpoenas don't generally recognise a tap-out, and the incoming Democratic committee chairmen seem rather less interested in wrestling with him than in examining his bank statements.
The chickens are coming home to roost. The henhouse is looking decidedly overcrowded, and the farmer has just appointed a new security guard. Unfortunately, he may have hired the wrong Dana White.
Keep that axe sharp. Washington's about to become a contact sport.
Sources and further reading